Comic Book Character Draft: The Final Top 100 Vote

[Anderson]

Here's the final step, people.

We've assembled quite a list of heroes and villains, now it's time to whittle down to the Top 100. Here's how it'll work. You pick 25 characters from any side mixed together based on what you like and what you think is important.

If someone is your number 1 pick, then that'll be worth 25 points. If he/she is number 25, that'll be worth 1 point. I'll pull it together and post the final list towards the end of the day and then we can call this draft a wrap.

[Anderson]

HEROES

7.12 Ambush Bug
2.17 Armstrong
5.5 Bad Horse, Dashiell
3.12 Banshee
1.2 Batman
3.9 Beast, The
3.4 Beta Ray Bill
2.7 Bigby Wolf
6.17 Bishop
5.1 Black Bolt
6.16 Black Cat
7.6 Black Panther
4.16 Blade
6.8 Blue Beetle II
7.10 Bluntman
3.6 Booster Gold
3.17 Boy Blue
6.6 Bug
7.3 Caped Wonder, The
6.3 Captain, The
1.12 Captain America
5.18 Captain Marvel (Billy Batson)
7.6 Captain Marvel (Mar-Vell)
6.13 Captain Nemo
7.10 Captain Pureheart
5.9 Cassidy
3.10 Cerebrus the Aardvark
7.10 Chronic
7.2 Cloak
7.9 Colossus
2.8 Conan the Barbarian
7.4 Concrete
3.2 Confessor, The
5.8 Creeper, The
7.2 Dagger
6.12 Dark Claw
1.15 Daredevil
1.7 Deadman
1.5 Deadpool
6.14 Deathlok
3.7 Death of the Endless
6.9 Dr. Manhattan
6.10 Dr. Strange
2.16 Donatello
7.9 Doop
7.13 Dreadstar
4.17 Dream of the Endless
6.11 Echo
7.11 Eternal Warrior
3.17 Flash II
7.1 Flash III
2.13 Fone Bone
7.8 Foolkiller I
7.5 Forge
5.17 Gambit
7.14 Gladiator
5.15 Goon, The
7.13 Grease Monkey
5.10 Green Arrow I
3.3 Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
4.3 Grendel II
4.6 Grimes, Rick
7.14 Guardian I
6.10 Harvester, Thorn
5.7 Havok
4.8 Hawkeye
2.3 Hawkman
4.9 Hayes, Molly
2.5 Hellboy
7.3 Howard the Duck
1.11 Hulk
1.14 Iceman
5.6 Invincible
1.9 Ogami Itto
2.18 Iron Fist
2.14 Iron Man
6.4 Jerusalem, Spider
2.12 Jesse Custer
1.10 John Constantine
6.15 Johnson, Lobster
2.15 Jonah Hex
3.11 Judge Dredd
6.15 Kutter, Daisy
4.15 Lobo
3.15 Lucifer
7.5 Madman
3.5 Madrox the Multiple Man
5.12 Martian Manhunter
5.2 Marv
7.12 Mask, The
6.7 Max
1.13 Mayor Mitchell Hundred
6.11 McDonald, Cal
6.13 Mercury, Max
7.7 Midnighter, The
1.17 Miracleman
7.11 Ms. Marvel I
6.17 Mr. Fantastic
2.6 Moon Knight
7.7 Morph (Exiles)
6.4 Murray, Wilhelmina
6.12 Namor, The Sub-Mariner
4.1 Nightcrawler
4.14 Nighthawk II
1.8 Nightwing
4.4 Nova I
6.3 Nuke II
7.1 Oracle (Barbara Gordon)
6.1 Orion
1.9 Paul the Samurai
7.1 Phantom Stranger, The
4.10 Pilgrim, Scott
7.3 Plastic Man
4.11 Power Girl
6.5 Professor X
7.11 Psylocke
5.14 Punisher, The
6.9 Question I
6.1 Red Hood II (Jason Todd)
6.6 Rocket Raccoon
5.16 Rogue
7.13 ROM: The Spaceknight
7.9 Rome, Remi
7.7 Rorschach
5.11 Sam
7.14 Sapien, Abe
5.3 Sasquatch I
7.2 Scarlet Witch (pre Bendis)
5.4 Scrooge McDuck
4.5 Sentry, The
3.14 Sgt. Rock
2.10 She-Hulk
7.6 Sherman, Liz
6.14 Silver Surfer, The
3.16 Snake Eyes
5.13 Snow, Elijah
6.5 Spawn
7.12 Spectre, The (Jim Corrigan
7.5 Spider-Girl
1.3 Spider-Man
7.8 Spirit, The
3.1 Stardust the Superwizard
1.4 Starman VII (Jack Knight)
7.4 Strange, Adam
4.13 Sunfire I
1.1 Superman
4.7 Swamp Thing
6.16 Tank Girl
6.2 Thing, The
2.2 Thor
2.9 Tick, The
2.1 Ultimate Captain America
6.2 Ultimate Invisible Woman
3.8 Ultimate Nick Fury
7.4 V
4.12 Vision, The
6.7 Washington, Martha
3.13 Williams, Detective Twitch
2.11 Witchblade (Sara Pezzini)
1.16 Wolverine
2.4 Wonder Woman
4.2 X-O Manowar
1.6 Yorrick Brown
6.8 Zatanna

VILLAINS

6.10 Abomination, The
6.14 Absorbing Man, The
3.15 Adversary, The
6.1 Alexander Luthor III
7.2 Annihilus
3.1 Anti-Monitor, The
2.11 Apocalypse
7.3 Arcade
3.10 Arcane, Anton
7.9 Bane
4.1 Baron Karza
2.5 Baron Zemo
6.16 Baroness, The
1.12 Black Adam
6.11 Black Manta
5.2 Black Mask
3.12 Bizarro
5.15 Blob, The
2.17 Braniac I
6.6 Brood, The
1.8 Bullseye
5.4 Captain Boomerang I
6.12 Captain Cold
7.8 Carnage
2.15 Catwoman
5.14 Circe
7.3 Clayface I
4.13 Clock King
4.4 Cobra Commander
5.10 Composite Superman
2.13 Corinthian, The
2.6 Crossbones
3.3 Darkseid
2.14 Dark Phoenix
6.8 Deadshot
2.3 Deathstroke the Terminator
7.14 Demon Bear, The
7.6 Destroyer
1.3 Dr. Doom
4.9 Dr. Light I
5.17 Dr. Octopus I
7.13 Doombots
2.9 Dormammu
1.17 Dowling, Randall
7.5 Electro
7.4 Emerald Empress
1.10 Etrigan the Demon
6.12 Fin Fang Foom
7.5 Firefly (DC)
7.2 Firelord
7.12 Floronic Man, The
7.6 Fu Manchu
5.6 Furnace
1.7 Galactus
4.7 General Anger, Dick
4.6 General Zod
6.17 Gog
3.7 Gorilla Grodd
7.8 Governor, The
2.2 Green Goblin I
4.3 Grendel I
6.5 Grundy, Solomon
6.2 Harada, Mr.
5.16 Harley Quinn
7.9 Herr Starr
6.5 Hobgoblin I
2.1 Hood, The
6.7 Hooded One, The
6.1 Hush
5.5 Jigsaw
7.1 Jody
6.9 Johnny the Homicidal Maniac
1.1 Joker, The
3.11 Judge Death
1.11 Juggernaut
3.5 Kang the Conqueror
5.11 Kevin
3.14 Kid Miracleman
6.15 Kingdok
1.6 Kingpin
7.1 Krakoa the Living Island
4.11 Kraven the Hunter
6.16 Lady Death
7.11 Legion
7.13 Letterman, David
1.13 Lex Luthor
7.13 Living Monolith, The
3.9 Lizard, The
3.4 Loki
7.3 Mad Hatter, The
7.11 Maestro, The
1.16 Magneto
7.8 Magog
7.4 Man-Bat
4.10 Mandarin I
7.11 Master Darque
4.12 Mephisto
6.8 Merlyn
6.9 Metallo
6.10 Mist II, The
2.16 Mr. Freeze
1.9 Mr. Gone
7.7 Mr. Mind
3.16 Mr. Mxyzptlk
6.13 Mr. Quimper
4.16 Mr. Sinister
6.11 Mr. Zsasz
4.15 M.O.D.O.K.
6.14 Mojo
5.12 Morbius, the Living Vampire
7.10 Moriarty, Professor James
7.10 Mysterio
5.8 Mystique
7.12 Nergal
5.1 Omega Red
4.17 Onslaught
1.2 Ozymandias
7.5 Parasite I
6.4 P'Gell
2.4 Poison Ivy
7.7 Powerhouse
7.6 Prometheus
6.3 Purple Man, The
4.8 Ragdoll
2.7 Ra's Al Ghul
7.10 Rasputin, Grigori
2.8 Red Skull, The
1.9 Yagyu Retsudō
6.4 Riddler, The
4.14 Sabretooth
1.14 Saint of All Killers
2.10 Sandman (Flint Marko)
6.15 Sauron
3.13 Scarecrow (Jonathan Crane)
6.17 Scarlet Witch, The
2.18 Sentinels, The
5.7 Shadow King
7.1 Shaggy Man II, The
7.7 Shrewmanoid, The
3.8 Sideways Bob
3.2 Silver Samurai, The
4.2 Sinestro
6.6 Sphinx, The
2.12 Starro
7.9 Steel Serpent I (Davos)
6.13 Stupid, Stupid Rat Creatures
3.17 Super-Skrull
7.4 Talia
5.13 TAO
5.3 Tarantula I
1.5 Taskmaster
7.2 Terrax the Tamer
1.4 Thanos
7.12 Tick, The (Barry)
1.15 Two-Face
5.9 Typhoid Mary
3.6 Ultron
3.17 Venom
5.18 Void, The
7.14 Vulture, The
6.7 Walter
7.14 White Queen, The
6.3 Wrecker
4.5 Zartan

[EdHocken]

I'm never good at ranking lists but here goes nothing.

1. Batman
2. Superman
3. Spiderman
4. Hellboy
5. Dr. Manhattan
6. Daredevil
7. Iron Man
8. Hulk
9. Thing
10. Professor X
11. The Tick
12. Mayor Mitchell Hundred
13. Scott Pilgrim
11. Sam
12. Conan The Barbarian
13. Sgt. Rock
14. Dr. Strange
15. The Punisher
16. Martha Washington
17. The Question
18. Marv
19. The Creeper
20. Deadpool
21. Max
22. Starman VII (Jack Knight)
23. Det. Twtich Williams
24. The Spirit
25. Spider-Girl

[Richard Dickson]

We doing 25 heroes and 25 villains or one combined list?

[Proyas]

considering we picked our favorites (for the most part), this seems redundant. You're not going to see most of my picks come up in a popularity contest. Ed, you have Prof. X up there twice too.

[Anderson]

We doing 25 heroes and 25 villains or one combined list?


1 combined list.

[Richard Dickson]

considering we picked our favorites (for the most part), this seems redundant.
Not really -- I may rank Batman higher than Thor, but he wasn't available for me to pick in Round 2.

[Anderson]

considering we picked our favorites (for the most part), this seems redundant.


It's not just for your picks, it's for the entire draft. So, that we can have some sort of official Top 100 list to satiate my OCD. Play into it, Proyas.

[Proyas]

considering we picked our favorites (for the most part), this seems redundant. You're not going to see most of my picks come up in a popularity contest. Ed, you have Prof. X up there twice too.

Might be better to take a look at everyone's completed roster and rank those. I still won't do well but at least that has to do with how well we strategized the draft along with it being a popularity contest.

dunno

[Anderson]

Well, there's two ways I can go about this. I can factor in personal choice in here for those that want it that way. Or, I could weigh the draft choices to the final goal.

What works for you?

[Proyas]

or better yet we can have a round robin, free for all bedlam match. Roster vs Roster, Hereos vs Villians to the death.

Its all good, I'm just particular ornery this time of year. goddamn sleighbells.

[EdHocken]

1 Combined list of Heroes and villans? Shit. That list is entirely of Heores. I ask for a do-over.

[Anderson]

1 Combined list of Heroes and villans? Shit. That list is entirely of Heores. I ask for a do-over.


There's always the edit button, Ed.

[Proyas]

also, since I am an anal retentive pusswad...what do we do about the characters that were selected more than once. There aren't that many of them, but they are there.

[Anderson]

I already went through the list and the order has kind of come together. I'm just looking for individual input to decide who goes where.

[Detonathor]

This was tough, so here it is:

1.The Spirit
2.Dr. Manhattan
3.Rorschach
4.Scott Pilgrim
5.The Tick
6.Hellboy
7.The Goon
8.Iron Man
9.The Joker
10.Dr. Doom
11.Daredevil
12.Fone Bone
13.Death of the Endless
14.Dark Phoenix
15.Etrigan the Demon
16.Ra's Al Ghul
17.Ozymandias
18.Martian Manhunter
19.Clock King
20.Mr. Freeze
21.Scarecrow (Jonathan Crane)
22.Green Goblin I
23.Galactus
24.Arcade
25.Apocalypse

[Anderson]

HEROES

5.10 Green Arrow I
3.3 Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
4.9 Hayes, Molly
4.1 Nightcrawler
1.3 Spider-Man
7.8 Spirit, The
1.4 Starman VII (Jack Knight)
1.1 Superman
6.8 Zatanna

VILLAINS

3.1 Anti-Monitor, The
1.8 Bullseye
6.8 Deadshot
2.3 Deathstroke the Terminator
1.3 Dr. Doom
7.9 Herr Starr
2.1 Hood, The
1.1 Joker, The
1.6 Kingpin
6.13 Mr. Quimper
1.14 Saint of All Killers
4.2 Sinestro
2.12 Starro
7.4 Talia
1.15 Two-Face
3.6 Ultron

[RathBandu]

This shit is unnecessary.

[Anderson]

The more I see it, the more it is.
Plus, I really don't feel like factoring this shit up.

Oh well, I hope everyone had fun.

[Chris Allen]

I definitely enjoyed it. This was a good idea, just would take a lot of work, and input.

The draft was great. I especially liked the end, mixing it up.

[Proyas]

We could vote who has the best stables of hereos or villians or rank them or whatever but it is redundant to go through the list and give a top 25. I mean how would you put someone taken in the 6th round in your top 25? It defy's logic.

[Anderson]

Don't get down, dude. It was a good idea, just would take a lot of work, and input.

The draft was great. I especially liked the end, mixing it up.


I'm not down, I just didn't appreciate the little comment from Rath. I was going to kill the Top 100 draft (which I didn't ask for) earlier today. But, I was under the impression that some people wanted to do it.

Less shit on my plate.

[RathBandu]

If people wanted to do a top 100 list, then they should have proposed that instead of doing a draft. As is, the list is pretty good and doesn't need to be whittled down, plus, as you said, less work for you.

[Anderson]

If people wanted to do a top 100 list, then they should have proposed that instead of doing a draft. As is, the list is pretty good and doesn't need to be whittled down, plus, as you said, less work for you.


Well, I've been getting a ton of PMs about it. And I was trying to do the best at appeasing all sides. That includes the people that didn't like their draft times.

I think it turned out well. It was interesting to see where everyone skewed. Never pegged myself for being that much of a DC person.

[RathBandu]

People need to suck it up, number 1, realize how a draft works, number 2, and stop bitching about their draft times, number 3. Bunch of babies.

[Anderson]

People need to suck it up, number 1, realize how a draft works, number 2, and stop bitching about their draft times, number 3. Bunch of babies.


Well, no shit.

But, it's all about fun. I don't have any money riding on someone picking up The Scarlet Witch, so it's not like we've got to break balls about it.

[Rob Hughes]

I'm proud to have picked the heroes and villians that noone else wanted. My plan worked. You know, the plan to pick the lamest ones.

[sunwukong]

Just a quick thought for the next time around ... at each person's turn, have them list, in order of preference, those picks people ahead of them had that they would have made.

e.g., I'm 4th and ahead of me people pick Supes, Bats and Ambush Bug. At my turn I pick Wolverine but note that my preferences would've been Bats, Supes, Wolvie and then The Bug. The stats geeks would record these lists and come up with a ranking system at the end of the draft.

[Anderson]

Just a quick thought for the next time around ... at each person's turn, have them list, in order of preference, those picks people ahead of them had that they would have made.

e.g., I'm 4th and ahead of me people pick Supes, Bats and Ambush Bug. At my turn I pick Wolverine but note that my preferences would've been Bats, Supes, Wolvie and then The Bug. The stats geeks would record these lists and come up with a ranking system at the end of the draft.


It's a thought.